Home Forums General Discussion Forum clock mainsprings in barrels Reply To: clock mainsprings in barrels

#51148
Bob Tascione
Moderator

    I too removed and replaced them by hand for many years. Winders are not cheap so this may be the only option one has. I do know that no matter how careful I was I was still risking distorting the spring. I also know that I distorted more than a few.

    I’ve known many clock smiths who also wind by hand and say they never distorted a spring. When they make this claim I have three canned questions that I ask them.

    First question: Have you ever encountered a coned mainspring? (of course they had seen many).
    Second question: What do you think caused the distortion?
    Third: How do you know the spring was distorted before you removed it?
    (got to have fun sometime) :D

    I would agree that if you are very careful then you will probably be okay much of the time but if you have a winder then why not be sure?

    Fred…if you don’t have the sleeves for your winder you can make them very easily from copper or pvc pipe fittings.

    Enjoy,
    Bob